In Florida, the Three Strikes Law is a sentencing law that is designed to impose harsher penalties on repeat offenders. The law is named after the baseball term "three strikes," which refers to a player receiving three strikes and being out of the game. In the legal context, this means that after an offender is convicted of three qualifying crimes, they face a mandatory minimum sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole. In this article, we will explore the details of Florida's Three Strikes Law, including how it works, its history, and its impact.
How Florida's Three Strikes Law Works
Florida's Three Strikes Law applies to defendants who have been convicted of three qualifying felonies. To qualify as a "strike," a felony offense must be a "forcible felony" under Florida law, such as murder, sexual battery, robbery, burglary, arson, or kidnapping. Non-violent offenses do not count as strikes under the law.
Once a defendant has been convicted of three qualifying felonies, they are subject to the Three Strikes Law. The law requires the judge to impose a mandatory minimum sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole. This means that the defendant will spend the rest of their life in prison, regardless of their age or health.
The Three Strikes Law is controversial because it takes discretion away from judges in sentencing. Judges are required to impose the mandatory sentence, even if they believe that it is too harsh. The law also does not allow for any exceptions or mitigating circumstances, such as the defendant's mental health, age, or other factors that could justify a lesser sentence.
Florida's Three Strikes Law History
Florida's Three Strikes Law was first passed in 1995 as part of a nationwide trend towards tougher sentencing laws. The law was initially introduced by then-Governor Lawton Chiles as a response to a spate of high-profile crimes committed by repeat offenders. The law was designed to deter repeat offenders by imposing harsher penalties and keeping them off the streets.
The law was passed with overwhelming support from both Republicans and Democrats, who saw it as a way to crack down on crime. At the time, Florida was one of several states that passed Three Strikes Laws, including California and Washington.
Since the law was enacted, it has been controversial. Critics argue that the law is too harsh and takes discretion away from judges in sentencing. They also argue that the law disproportionately affects minorities and the poor, who are more likely to be repeat offenders.
In response to the criticism, Florida lawmakers have made several changes to the law over the years. In 1999, the law was amended to allow judges to depart from the mandatory sentence in certain circumstances. For example, if the defendant committed their third strike when they were a juvenile, the judge can consider a lesser sentence. The law was amended again in 2016 to allow judges to depart from the mandatory sentence if the defendant committed a non-violent third strike.
Impact of Florida's Three Strikes Law
Since its enactment, Florida's Three Strikes Law has had a significant impact on the state's criminal justice system. Supporters of the law argue that it has deterred repeat offenders and reduced crime. They also argue that the law has kept dangerous criminals off the streets and made communities safer.
Critics of the law, however, argue that it has had unintended consequences. They argue that the law has resulted in harsh and disproportionate sentences for non-violent offenders. They also argue that the law has contributed to the over-incarceration of minorities and the poor, who are more likely to be repeat offenders.
In recent years, there has been a growing movement to reform or repeal Three Strikes Laws across the country. Advocates for reform argue that the laws are overly punitive and do not take into account the individual circumstances of each case. They also argue that the laws are expensive to enforce and have not been effective in reducing crime.
In Florida, there have been several high-profile cases that have drawn attention to the impact of the Three Strikes Law. For example, in 2014, a man named Robert DuBoise was released from prison after serving 37 years for a crime he did not commit. DuBoise had been convicted of a robbery and murder in 1983, but DNA evidence later proved his innocence. DuBoise had previously been convicted of two other felonies, which made him eligible for a mandatory life sentence under the Three Strikes Law.
DuBoise's case highlighted the flaws in the Three Strikes Law and the need for reform. In response, lawmakers in Florida have introduced bills to modify the law and give judges more discretion in sentencing. However, these efforts have been met with resistance from some lawmakers and law enforcement officials who believe that the law is necessary to protect public safety.
Florida's Three Strikes Law is a controversial sentencing law that has been in place since 1995. The law requires mandatory life sentences for defendants who have been convicted of three qualifying felonies, regardless of the circumstances. While the law has been credited with reducing crime and keeping dangerous criminals off the streets, critics argue that it is overly punitive and has contributed to the over-incarceration of minorities and the poor. In recent years, there have been efforts to reform or repeal Three Strikes Laws across the country, including in Florida. While the future of the law remains uncertain, it is clear that the debate over its effectiveness and fairness will continue.
Free Criminal Defense Case Reviews & Consultations - 24/7!
With decades of combined legal experience, Florida BUI defense attorneys at Musca Law are dedicated to helping those accused fight their charges and protect their freedom. We understand arrests can happen at any time, which is why we are available 24-hours a day to take your call. If you were arrested or facing questioning by law enforcement, contact our law firm as soon as possible at 1-888-484-5057 to see how we can best protect you.