What Happens If I Refuse a DUI Test in Florida But Wasn't Impaired?

May 27, 2025

Refusing a DUI Test Can Have Serious Consequences in Florida, But You Have Defenses — Here's What You Need to Know

When you're pulled over under suspicion of DUI in Florida, you may be asked to take a breath, blood, or urine test to determine your level of impairment. But what happens if you refuse the test? Even if you know you weren't impaired, the consequences can be severe, and the situation can get complicated fast. I've had clients who were certain they were sober and still faced significant penalties simply because they refused a test.

Let me explain the law, the consequences of refusing a DUI test, and why having a private attorney to fight your case is crucial. I'll also share a real-life example from a case I won, showing you just how important it is to have the right defense strategy.

The Law Behind DUI Test Refusals in Florida

Under Florida Statutes § 316.1932(1), also known as the Implied Consent Law, you are legally required to submit to a DUI test if law enforcement has probable cause to believe that you were driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs. This law essentially means that by operating a vehicle on Florida roads, you've agreed to take a breath, blood, or urine test if asked by law enforcement.

Here’s what § 316.1932(1) says:

"Any person who accepts the privilege extended by this chapter to drive a motor vehicle in this state shall be deemed to have given consent to the testing provided for in s. 316.1932..."

This consent is automatic, and refusal comes with immediate consequences. However, what if you weren't impaired? What if you were sober but still refused?

Consequences of Refusing a DUI Test in Florida

Florida law is clear: if you refuse a DUI test, the consequences can be just as severe as being convicted for DUI. Here's what happens:

License Suspension – Under Florida Statutes § 322.2615, a refusal to submit to a breath, blood, or urine test results in an automatic driver's license suspension. For a first refusal, your license is suspended for one year. If you've previously refused a DUI test or have had prior DUI offenses, the suspension can increase to 18 months.
No Opportunity for a Hardship License – If you refuse a test and your license is suspended, you won't be eligible for a hardship license right away. A hardship license, which lets you drive for limited purposes (like work or school), is only available in certain circumstances, and refusing the test often eliminates that option.
Use of Refusal Against You in Court – The fact that you refused a test can be used as evidence against you in court. Prosecutors often argue that your refusal is an indication of guilt, implying that you refused because you knew you were impaired. This can make it harder to fight your case.
Increased Penalties for Future DUI Convictions – Refusing a DUI test in Florida also counts as a "prior refusal" if you're arrested again for DUI in the future, leading to more severe penalties, including longer license suspensions and higher fines.

Real-World Example: A Case I Won

Let me tell you about a real case I handled where my client refused a DUI test but wasn't impaired.

My client, "John," was pulled over after a late-night driving incident. The officer noticed he was driving a bit erratically, but there was no smell of alcohol on his breath, and he was perfectly coherent. However, the officer suspected drug use and asked John to take a DUI test. John, knowing he was sober, refused the test, but the officer arrested him anyway.

The consequences were immediate: John's license was suspended for a year due to the refusal, and the officer tried to use the refusal as evidence against him in court. We immediately filed a motion to dismiss based on the following:

The lack of probable cause to believe John was impaired (there was no evidence of drug or alcohol use).
The absence of any tests showing impairment.
The fact that John was not impaired and his behavior could be attributed to fatigue and stress, not intoxication.

We fought the case by proving that John's refusal didn't indicate guilt, especially considering there was no supporting evidence of impairment. The court ruled in our favor, and the charges were dropped. John's license suspension was also overturned because we demonstrated that the officer didn't have probable cause for the arrest in the first place.

This case is a great example of why it's crucial to have a private attorney when facing a DUI test refusal charge, even if you weren't impaired. A good defense lawyer knows how to challenge the validity of the arrest and show that the refusal doesn't necessarily mean you are guilty.

Why You Need a Private Attorney in DUI Refusal Cases

When it comes to refusing a DUI test in Florida, the consequences are serious, even if you weren't impaired. The police and prosecution will use your refusal against you, and it's essential to have someone in your corner who understands the nuances of Florida DUI law and how to protect your rights. A public defender may not have the time or resources to fight these charges effectively. But as a private attorney, I focus on the details that can make or break a case.

Here's what I do for clients facing DUI test refusal charges:

Challenge the legality of the stop – I examine whether the officer had proper cause to stop you in the first place. Without reasonable suspicion, your entire case may be thrown out.
Challenge the refusal consequences – I will fight the license suspension and work to have your driving privileges reinstated or minimized.
Negotiate alternatives – In some cases, I can help you reduce penalties or even avoid a DUI conviction by challenging the evidence the prosecution is relying on, including the refusal.
Provide personalized defense strategies – Every case is different. I look at all the factors, including the officer's behavior, your actions, and the circumstances surrounding the refusal, to build a defense strategy tailored to your situation.

The key is not letting the consequences of the refusal be used against you unfairly. And most importantly, it's about ensuring your rights are protected throughout the process.

Florida Statutes to Consider When Facing DUI Test Refusal Charges

Here are some relevant Florida statutes you should be aware of when refusing a DUI test:

Florida Statutes § 316.1932(1) – Implied Consent Law: Requires drivers to submit to DUI tests when requested by law enforcement.
Florida Statutes § 322.2615 – Implied Consent Refusal Penalties: Details the consequences of refusing a DUI test, including license suspension.
Florida Statutes § 316.193 – DUI Penalties: The statute under which DUI charges are typically filed, including penalties for conviction.
Florida Statutes § 322.2616 – Administrative Review: Allows drivers to request a hearing to challenge the suspension of their license.

Understanding these statutes is essential to fighting DUI test refusal charges, and having an experienced attorney who is familiar with these laws can make all the difference.

If you've refused a DUI test in Florida and weren't impaired, don't assume that all is lost. The consequences are serious, but with the right legal representation, you can fight to protect your rights and minimize the impact on your future.

Musca Law, P.A. has a team of experienced criminal defense attorneys dedicated to defending people charged with a criminal or traffic offense. We are available 24/7/365 at 1-888-484-5057 for your FREE consultation. We have 30 office locations in Florida and serve all counties in Florida.

FAQs – DUI Test Refusal in Florida

What happens if I refuse a DUI test in Florida, but I wasn't impaired?

Even if you were not impaired, refusing a DUI test still comes with significant consequences. Your license will be automatically suspended, and the refusal can be used against you in court. This means that the prosecution may argue that you refused the test because you knew you were impaired, even if you weren't. The best defense is to have an attorney challenge the refusal and argue the circumstances of your case.

Can I fight a DUI refusal charge if I was sober?

Yes, it is possible to fight a DUI refusal charge, even if you were sober. An experienced DUI defense lawyer can challenge the legality of the traffic stop, the officer's assessment, and the consequences of the refusal. Your lawyer can argue that you were not impaired and that your refusal should not be used as evidence against you.

How long will my license be suspended if I refuse a DUI test?

If you refuse a DUI test in Florida, your driver's license will be automatically suspended for one year for a first refusal. If you've refused a DUI test in the past or have a prior DUI conviction, the suspension can be extended to up to 18 months.

What if I wasn't impaired but was still arrested for DUI after refusing the test?

Even if you weren't impaired, refusing a DUI test can still lead to an arrest. However, your lawyer can investigate the case, file motions to dismiss, and challenge the officer's reasoning for the refusal and arrest. The absence of impairment and the lack of test results may be used to argue that the case should be dismissed.

Can a refusal be used as evidence in court?

Yes, in Florida, the prosecution can use your refusal to submit to a DUI test as evidence that you were guilty of DUI. However, this is not a certainty. A strong DUI defense attorney can challenge the implications of the refusal and fight to prevent it from being used to strengthen the prosecution's case.

Can a DUI refusal be expunged from my record in Florida?

Generally, a refusal to take a DUI test in Florida cannot be expunged or sealed, as it is related to a criminal offense. However, if the DUI charges are dropped or dismissed, the refusal may not result in a permanent criminal record. Discussing this with a criminal defense lawyer is essential to understand your options.

Contact Musca Law 24/7/365 at 1-888-484-5057 For Your FREE Consultation

Empower Yourself - GET TRUSTED DEFENSE

Get Your Free Case Evaluation

DUI & Criminal Defense Lawyers in Florida